1. Create a Foundation of Trust and Psychological Safety
Before diving into performance discussions, it’s crucial to establish a foundation of trust. Psychological safety—a sense that it’s safe to speak up without fear of retribution—is a key driver of team performance. To build this, encourage openness and vulnerability by modeling these behaviors yourself. Start conversations by affirming the team member’s value and contributions, creating a positive tone that sets the stage for constructive dialogue.
2. Prepare for the Conversation
Preparation is essential. Review past performance metrics, feedback from peers, and notes from prior conversations. More importantly, consider the individual’s strengths, goals, and challenges. This preparation enables you to tailor the discussion, making it relevant and meaningful. Ask yourself, What do I want this person to walk away with? How can this conversation support their growth and the team’s objectives?
3. Use a Coaching Approach
Rather than simply giving feedback, adopt a coaching mindset. This involves asking open-ended questions that invite the team member to reflect and share their perspective. Questions like:
- “What has been working well for you in your role?”
- “What challenges have you encountered, and how can I support you in overcoming them?”
- “What skills or resources would help you achieve your goals?”
4. Focus on Strengths and Future Goals
While it’s important to address areas for improvement, framing the conversation around strengths and aspirations can be more motivating. Discuss how the individual’s unique strengths contribute to team success and explore how these can be leveraged further. Shift from focusing solely on past performance to setting future goals, emphasizing growth and development.
5. Follow Up and Follow Through
Performance conversations shouldn’t be a one-time event. Regularly check in to revisit the goals and action plans discussed. Celebrate progress, address any barriers, and adjust objectives as needed. Consistency demonstrates your commitment to their success and reinforces accountability.
A Final Note
Effective performance conversations are not just about evaluating results—they’re an opportunity to build relationships, align on expectations, and inspire growth. By fostering trust, preparing thoroughly, embracing a coaching mindset, and maintaining regular follow-ups, you can turn performance discussions into a cornerstone of your team’s success.
Empower your team to thrive by making these conversations a meaningful and consistent part of your leadership approach.
CEO, Head Coach and Author
Potentials Realized | Group Coaching Essentials
Leadership | Teamwork | Coaching
Contact: 1-416-996-8326
Email: [email protected]
Instagram:@ReconnectingWorkspaces @CoachingBusinessBuilder
Looking for bite-sized boosts to your work as a coach, leader or during your onboarding process? Check out our Card Decks. Now available on Deckible:
90-Day Guide for Success – Deck 1 – Days 1 – 30 (for new leaders, onboarding or those wanting a sprint) – https://bit.ly/90dayguidedeck1
ACTIVATE Your Group and Team Coaching Superpowers (for coaches) – https://bit.ly/activatedeck
Pick up a copy of Reconnecting Workspaces: Pathways to Thrive in the Virtual, Remote and Hybrid World at Amazon – https://bit.ly/reconnectingworkspaces.
Check out my latest TEDx talk – Coaching Teams Through Chaos at https://www.ted.com/talks/jennifer_britton_coaching_teams_through_chaos
Set up a call with myself or my team to learn more about how we can support you through our card decks, customized team development and leadership training, OR award-winning ICF CCE approved Coach Training programs – https://calendly.com/jennbritton/15-minute-exploration-call