1. Create a Culture of Trust and Openness
Before introducing peer feedback, it’s crucial to establish a foundation of trust. Team members need to feel safe sharing their perspectives without fear of judgment or retaliation. Encourage open communication and model vulnerability as a leader by inviting feedback on your own performance. When trust is a cornerstone of your team culture, feedback is seen as an opportunity for growth rather than criticism.
2. Normalize Feedback as a Daily Practice
Feedback shouldn’t be limited to formal reviews or meetings—it works best when integrated into everyday interactions. Normalize giving and receiving feedback by emphasizing its value in team discussions and encouraging it in real-time. This makes feedback a natural part of the team’s workflow, reducing the pressure often associated with formalized settings.
3. Provide Training on Effective Feedback
Not everyone is naturally skilled at giving feedback, and poor delivery can lead to misunderstandings or resentment. Equip your team with tools and techniques for delivering constructive, actionable, and respectful feedback. Introduce models like the SBI (Situation-Behavior-Impact) framework, which helps individuals focus on specific behaviors and their effects, avoiding generalizations or personal judgments.
4. Introduce Structured Feedback Opportunities
While informal feedback is important, structured opportunities can encourage participation and consistency. Implement feedback rounds in meetings, peer review sessions for projects, or dedicated feedback days. For example, create a monthly “Feedback Friday” where team members pair up to exchange observations on recent work.
5. Encourage Positive Feedback
Feedback isn’t just about addressing areas for improvement; it’s also about recognizing strengths and celebrating successes. Encourage team members to share what they appreciate about one another’s contributions. Positive feedback reinforces desired behaviors, boosts morale, and strengthens relationships.
6. Lead by Example
As a leader, demonstrate the behaviors you want to see. Share feedback openly with your peers and team members, showing how it helps you grow. A transparent approach creates a ripple effect, making others more likely to embrace feedback themselves.
A Final Thought
Peer-to-peer feedback is a dynamic way to build stronger, more cohesive teams. By creating a safe environment, normalizing feedback, providing training, and leading by example, you empower your team to take ownership of their development and create a culture of continuous improvement. Start small, and watch the ripple effects transform your team dynamics.
CEO, Head Coach and Author
Potentials Realized | Group Coaching Essentials
Leadership | Teamwork | Coaching
Contact: 1-416-996-8326
Email: [email protected]
Instagram:@ReconnectingWorkspaces @CoachingBusinessBuilder
Looking for bite-sized boosts to your work as a coach, leader or during your onboarding process? Check out our Card Decks. Now available on Deckible:
90-Day Guide for Success – Deck 1 – Days 1 – 30 (for new leaders, onboarding or those wanting a sprint) – https://bit.ly/90dayguidedeck1
ACTIVATE Your Group and Team Coaching Superpowers (for coaches) – https://bit.ly/activatedeck
Pick up a copy of Reconnecting Workspaces: Pathways to Thrive in the Virtual, Remote and Hybrid World at Amazon – https://bit.ly/reconnectingworkspaces.
Check out my latest TEDx talk – Coaching Teams Through Chaos at https://www.ted.com/talks/jennifer_britton_coaching_teams_through_chaos
Set up a call with myself or my team to learn more about how we can support you through our card decks, customized team development and leadership training, OR award-winning ICF CCE approved Coach Training programs – https://calendly.com/jennbritton/15-minute-exploration-call